Hamptons Verified

← Back to restaurants

Cuisine

Italian

Nick & Toni's

East Hampton

The Hamptons institution. Wood-fired everything, garden vegetables, and a guest list that spans presidents to publishers.

Reserve on Resy →

Tutto il Giorno

Sag Harbor

Hand-rolled pasta, southern Italian classics, and a sceney bar that hums year-round.

Reserve on Resy →

Sant Ambroeus Southampton

Southampton

Milanese power-lunch on Main Street. Order the risotto and people-watch.

Reserve on Resy →

Cittanuova

East Hampton

Milanese trattoria with thin-crust pizza, kid-friendly patio, year-round hours.

Reserve on Resy →

Il Buco al Mare

Amagansett

The NoHo institution's Hamptons outpost. Whole-fish grilling, hand-cut pasta, scene-y but earned.

Reserve on Resy →

Il Capuccino

Sag Harbor

Since 1973. Red sauce, Chianti bottles on the walls, and the sweetest year-round date night in Sag.

Pellegrino's Pizza Bar & Restaurant

Southampton

Verified via Google Places sweep (v6.250.2). Editorial pass pending.

American Pie Pizzeria Southampton

Southampton

Verified via Google Places sweep (v6.250.2). Editorial pass pending.

Melrose East Restaurant and Pizza

Southampton

Verified via Google Places sweep (v6.250.2). Editorial pass pending.

Fresco Pizza & Deli

Southampton

Verified via Google Places sweep (v6.250.2). Editorial pass pending.

FRANKIE'S Fabulous Italiano

East Hampton

Verified via Google Places sweep (v6.250.2). Editorial pass pending.

Villa Italian Specialties

East Hampton

Verified via Google Places sweep (v6.250.2). Editorial pass pending.

Luigi's Italian Specialties

East Hampton

Verified via Google Places sweep (v6.250.2). Editorial pass pending.

Fierro's Pizza

East Hampton

Verified via Google Places sweep (v6.250.2). Editorial pass pending.

Springs Pizza

East Hampton

Verified via Google Places sweep (v6.250.2). Editorial pass pending.

Pacheco's Deli & Pizza

East Hampton

Verified via Google Places sweep (v6.250.2). Editorial pass pending.

Pineneck Pizza

Sag Harbor

Verified via Google Places sweep (v6.250.2). Editorial pass pending.

Sausages Pizza & Pastabilities

Montauk

Verified via Google Places sweep (v6.250.2). Editorial pass pending.

Pizza Village

Montauk

Verified via Google Places sweep (v6.250.2). Editorial pass pending.

Fierro’s Pizza Montauk

Montauk

Verified via Google Places sweep (v6.250.2). Editorial pass pending.

American Pie Pizzeria - Bridgehampton

Bridgehampton

Verified via Google Places sweep (v6.250.2). Editorial pass pending.

The Pizza Place

Bridgehampton

Verified via Google Places sweep (v6.250.2). Editorial pass pending.

Fini Pizza Amagansett

Amagansett

Verified via Google Places sweep (v6.250.2). Editorial pass pending.

Scotto's Italian deli & meat market

Hampton Bays

Verified via Google Places sweep (v6.250.2). Editorial pass pending.

Uncle Joe’s Pizza & Parlour - The Hamptons Institution Since 1968

Hampton Bays

Verified via Google Places sweep (v6.250.2). Editorial pass pending.

The Pizza Place - Hampton Bays

Hampton Bays

Verified via Google Places sweep (v6.250.2). Editorial pass pending.

Domino's Pizza

Hampton Bays

Verified via Google Places sweep (v6.250.2). Editorial pass pending.

Brunetti Pizza

Westhampton Beach

Verified via Google Places sweep (v6.250.2). Editorial pass pending.

Tonino's Pizza

Westhampton Beach

Verified via Google Places sweep (v6.250.2). Editorial pass pending.

Firehouse Pizza

Westhampton Beach

Verified via Google Places sweep (v6.250.2). Editorial pass pending.

East Quogue Pizza & Deli

Quogue

Verified via Google Places sweep (v6.250.2). Editorial pass pending.

Trattoria Dal Forno

North Haven

Verified via Google Places sweep (v6.250.2). Editorial pass pending.

Ludal's Italian Restaurant

North Haven

Verified via Google Places sweep (v6.250.2). Editorial pass pending.

Brick Oven La Capricciosa Pizza

Greenport

Verified via Google Places sweep (v6.250.2). Editorial pass pending.

1943 Pizza Bar

Greenport

Verified via Google Places sweep (v6.250.2). Editorial pass pending.

PIZZA UNO INC

Southold

Verified via Google Places sweep (v6.250.2). Editorial pass pending.

Fiocha Pizza

Mattituck

Verified via Google Places sweep (v6.250.2). Editorial pass pending.

Michelangelo Pizzeria

Mattituck

Verified via Google Places sweep (v6.250.2). Editorial pass pending.

Primavera pizza

Mattituck

Verified via Google Places sweep (v6.250.2). Editorial pass pending.

Roma Pizzeria

Cutchogue

Verified via Google Places sweep (v6.250.2). Editorial pass pending.

Alba Spiaggia

Montauk

Cucina Alba's East End debut sits dockside at Montauk Yacht Club: coastal Italian around the day's catch, a raw bar, and an easy-drinking wine list with boats a few feet from the tables. Time it for sunset over the water.